Issue 11: The Potential of Cliché
His prose is upfront about his position as an enthusiastic, charming, and easily charmed amateur who is, above all, drawn to beauty and delight. He reflects, 'Honestly, I didn't know much about plants — I would say, "How beautiful. What is this flower called?" and a gardener who'd influenced the landscaping of an entire region would answer very carefully, "Bob, it's a geranium."1 By charting his journey from innocence to relative experience in horticulture, Glück is able to bring the processes of naming and describing the world to the fore. Elsewhere, he writes how "to describe how the world is organized may be the same as organizing the world," and learning about gardening helps to elaborate the scope of description.2 His interviewees are obsessed with creating their own miniature worlds in a way that is eccentric, extreme, but also totally ordinary, totally normative. Their passion is for the clichéd - for prize roses named for movie stars, for English country gardens transposed to a Californian climate, for coffee mugs bearing slogans like "God put me on earth to accomplish a certain number of things. Right now I'm so far behind, I will never die." The owner of said coffee mug saw it and thought, "that's me. I just keep trying to cram one more flower in." Glück is drawn to these, leaving them in rather than pruning them out.
In a reflection on his gardening philosophy, "Let Strong Color Breathe," Glück considers how he might bring his wide range of influences together. To do so, he turns to filmmaking for analogy. Some of the parallels between fiction and gardening that Glück makes are quite blatant: "I don't want my garden to be a Hollywood movie on steroids that clobbers me over the head, more like a foreign film from my formative period, slow and considered, allusive, an expression I bring myself to." In this piece, he satirizes a familiar cultural debate about modernism, postmodernism, and the anxiety of influence. Is his dream garden an invidious aesthetic program? Is it wrong to build a garden to look already-old, to pretend to inherit another culture's nostalgia? Would this be any different from the French chateau next to the fake English cottages that line the streets? Glück likes these: they provide him with the opportunity to appropriate the grandeur of someone else's past. For him, a conspicuously futuristic aesthetic desperately signaling its newness is overrated: "who wants to go back to the future?" The description of his ideal garden that he settles on is as follows:
It is a colloquium of the clamorous voices of memory — urging and intimating, sometimes reaching satisfying agreements and sometimes staking out contradictions, catching allusions and sharing jokes, making asides and getting back to the point, sporting with irony and flirting with whimsy, and finally concluding, somehow, that some particular ideas are right for a particular site at a particular moment. So, I will persevere with my overlapping complexities and endeavor to keep the final result simple, focused and a little dumb. The Poetics of Gardens cites Sakuteiki, an 11th-century book on garden art, which advises us to consider the site, study the past, recall the places that were beautiful, and appropriate that which moves us the most.
This is a philosophy that sounds a lot like his fiction. Like his dream garden, these capture the present as they seek out a new context for pleasure that makes life livable. It is personal and collective; discursive and chatty, at the same time as being a little "dumb" (unspeaking, in outdated ableist parlance that is no longer used).
"Ordinary Ironies": Clichés and the Aggression of Naming
Those familiar with Glück's writing know that it is in commodity culture - the domain of the cliché - where the individual meets the collective. In his own account of New Narrative, "Long Note on New Narrative," Glück looks back to the 1970s and 1980s to articulate how commodity culture was inseparable from writing queer life. Commodity culture elaborated their existence at a time where there was a pressure for the homosexual subject to parse themselves in language. The minority identity is often called upon to speak, to provide teachable lessons, disclose their traumas and make themselves worthy of subjecthood: to reassure the dominant culture of their similarities and thereby flatten difference. Glück writes that there was a simultaneous over and underrepresentation of gay identity in the mainstream that reflected a "resoundingly coherent image of myself back to me — an image so unjust that it amounted to a tyranny that I could not turn my back on. We had been disastrously described by the mainstream — a naming whose most extreme (though, not uncommon) expression was physical violence." 3 While the poetry of disjunction and abstraction represented, to him, a luxurious idealism where the speaking subject could reject the confines of representation and disappear into the vast horizon of language itself, this freedom was not afforded to him: his body was "dense with homosexuality." 4 At the time, gay identity had also "not yet settled into just another nationalism and it was new enough to know its own constructed-ness. 5 In urban spaces, genuine community emerged between strangers, different classes and ethnicities. Crucially, this "community was not destroyed by commodity culture; instead it was founded in commodity culture."6