Issue 11: The Potential of Cliché
This concern drives the plot of Emily Henry's third romance Book Lovers which, like Beach Read, self-consciously trades in clichés, opening with a declaration from literary agent Nora Stephens that "when books are your life — or in my case, your job — you get pretty good at guessing where a story is going."1 Working as a skeptical gatekeeper of taste, Nora's role seemingly confirms Laura McGrath's assertion that "no figure is more influential ... than the literary agent.2 Indeed, Book Lovers is a novel essentially about influence and control. Framed as a battle of narrative constraints, Nora sees cliché everywhere including her personal life, accepting that she is the uptight, careerist "City Person" in a small-town romance novel, who will inevitably be dumped for the more down-to-earth heroine. She cannot find love because, as her younger sister Libby explains, "[w]ork always comes first for her" (224). Secretly hoping to convince Nora to move out of New York with her and her family, Libby orchestrates a plan to rewrite Nora's City Person life into a small-town romance of her own. Dragging Nora on a vacation to the town of Sunshine Falls in North Carolina, Libby supplies a checklist of narrative tropes for Nora to fulfill, including skinny dipping, saving a local business, and going on dates with locals.
The reluctant Nora, however, holds fast to work, compulsively checking emails, fielding calls from clients at all hours, and reading manuscripts despite her sister's protests. As the novel reveals, Nora's obsession with work and her emotional guardedness are the product of the unexpected death of their single mother, an aspiring actress, when Nora was in college and Libby was still a teenager. Faced with mountains of bills and debt, Nora supplemented her minimum wage job at a bookstore with a series of odd jobs, working as a waitress, tutor, and even ghostwriter for her classmates' papers. But rather than bemoan the economic precarity of their upbringing, Nora instead romanticizes it, characterizing their mother as "spread thin," but "also full of life, ecstatic to be chasing her dreams" of being an actress (223). Libby, however, offers an alternative interpretation: "Mom was broke, tired, and lonely. She put her career ahead of absolutely everything and was miserable because of it" (223). Here, their differing assessments of whether their mother's work left her feeling "ecstatic" or "miserable" is partially a litmus test for the two sisters' own feelings about the pursuit of a dream career, but also a question of reading their mother's own feelings. Narrated by Nora, the novel does not allow room to fully settle the issue, but articulates the novel's problem of defining what a happy ending might look like; for Nora, happiness is in the optimistic pursuit of the future, whereas for Libby, unhappiness is a reality of the present.
Sara Ahmed describes this fantasy toward the future as a belief that "happiness is what we would have, if that thing did not get in the way."3 For Nora, her job is not necessarily a source of happiness as much as it is control, but Nora rejects the idea that work stands in the way of personal happiness. Instead believing that personal relationships are at fault, Nora thinks about watching all of her
friends in relationships make compromise after compromise, shrinking themselves until they were nothing but a piece of a whole, until all their stories came from the past, and their career aspirations, their friends, and their apartments were replaced by our aspirations, our friends, our apartment. Half lives that could be taken from them without any warning (112).
Ever the reader, Nora views her friends as retired authors, no longer capable of telling their own stories. And contrasted by her friends' "shrinking" selves, Nora's expanding appraisal of clauses and qualifications performs both a verbal shielding and defense of her own life decisions. Grammatically rendering her friend's "half lives" into a half sentence, Nora instead views herself as fully complete without a love interest. But as a romance, Book Lovers demands that Nora reassess her own views toward love; what stands in the way of Nora's total happiness, the novel implies, is her belief that she can maintain full narrative control of her own life by retreating to the safety of the generic cliché.