Issue 11: The Potential of Cliché
There are many reasons to reach for auto-authorizing self-reflection in today's alienated and exploitative critical landscape. In the academic labor market, stable, living-wage jobs are increasingly the exception, and precariously employed, underpaid scholars do the majority of teaching. The systematic underfunding of universities by state and national governments in the U.S. and the U.K., and the rationalization of academic departments in private institutions, are born of the same ideological motives.1 Cost-cutting, so-called efficiency measures, and the stripping away of labor rights to make workers fluid and disposable according to the financialized whims of institutions — these are measures for which the ground has been meticulously laid in the cultural sphere, ever-vigilant against academic "jargon" and the vanity of intellectual extravagance. Jargon, cliché's evil twin, is levelled at academics and critics to discredit and devalue intellectual work while the conditions of its production are quietly dismantled. Liberal centrist pundits, who loudly decry anti-intellectualism in its associations with authoritarianism, are more than willing to overlook anti-intellectualism as a core principle of neoliberal economic policy, which attempts to raze the landscape of critique.
In this context, it's unsurprising that critics turn to personal narratives: it's less expensive to write about yourself than to do research, which requires steady institutional support and resources. If you're trying to scrabble together articles and book proposals without library access, in between multiple adjunct teaching jobs, or in hours of daylight before your alt-ac job starts, writing from experience might look more expedient. At the same time, even a CV stacked with books and articles cannot get you a job that no longer exists. If there are no jobs and no hope of new ones arising, we might turn to the false promise that Erik Baker has mapped across over a century of Western culture: that with enough effort and charm we can "make our own job."2 If we could just exhibit our super-heroic personal qualities, we might super-heroically transcend the exploitative and unjust conditions of academic labor. These super-heroic personal qualities are expressed, surely, through the witty social media presence, the personally inflected essays and opinion pieces, the SubStack or podcast, and ultimately the work of autotheory, which makes immediate and intimate the individual critic to her readers, particularly, perhaps, those on an upcoming hiring committee.3
Reading with Adorno and Horkheimer, it's hard not to suspect that writing about oneself may become, all too easily, a self-soothing attempt to individualize oneself just enough, in a sense that we hope has not already been subsumed by the market. In this context, it is not just autotheory as a marketable publishing category that risks cliché in its generic repetitions, but the managed chaos of selfhood itself, slowly regularized across years of autotheoretical and essayistic narratives.4 At some point, writing the self might become less an exercise in forging solidarity across personal difference, and more a performance of easily consumable tropes of individuality. We find parts of ourselves reflected in these narratives, and, like the armchair produced for our particular income level and educational background, feel confirmed in our quirks, without the risk or need to challenge or critique the systems that produce and validate them.
- On the decline of state funding for universities in the U.S. and U.K., see e.g.: Mary Ellen Flannery, "State Funding for Higher Education Still Lagging," NEA Today, October 25, 2022; American Academy of Arts & Sciences, Public Research Universities: Changes in State Funding, September 2015; Joe Lewis and Paul Bolton, "Higher Education Funding: Trends and Challenges," House of Commons Library, July 16, 2024. On the ideological roots of the transformation of funding in U.S. higher education, see e.g. Beth Mintz, "Neoliberalism and the Crisis in Higher Education: The Cost of Ideology," The American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 80, no. 1 (2021:, 79-112.[⤒]
- Erik Baker, Make Your Own Job: How the Entrepreneurial Work Ethic Exhausted America (Harvard University Press, 2025).[⤒]
- See Harriet S. Hughes, "The Entrepreneurial Essay," ELH (forthcoming Spring 2027).[⤒]
- Another example in the academic marketplace: the academic job application. A somewhat more degrading version of the university application essay, the academic job application requires the writer to navigate just the right amount of personal cliché, entrepreneurial optimism, and supposed novelty and individuality.[⤒]