Issue 11: The Potential of Cliché
Cliché, as a critical object, helps to illuminate our too-earnest and anxious belief in our own performances of originality. It helps us to understand why, in our cultural and economic context, we hunger to individualize, and to analyze the predefined forms that shape our process of individualization. At best, cliché can productively warn us away from both the ease of unthinking massification, and the lure of solipsistic personalism.
This issue is being published in a historical moment characterized by an increasingly technologized inhumanity: a post-truth political landscape depleted of strong institutions, and in which rigorous reporting and critical thought face an uphill battle against a for-profit media landscape populated by AI-generated content, propaganda, and misinformation. Our attention to cliché, in this context, is not just a bid for more refined thought and nuanced expression, but for humanity in the face of an obliteratingly inhuman economic and political order. Cliché marks the outer bounds of a horseshoe, inside of which lies the vibrant, contested, and urgent space of democratic activity. On one side of this horseshoe: our ineradicable sociality, which can all too easily slide into apathetic and fearful homogeneity. On the other: our ineradicable individuality, prey to a banal and terrible myopia of self-interest and self-protection. One of criticism's jobs is to burnish this curve, and to negotiate its terms. Yet the conditions that enable creative, critical human work are being stripped away. Criticism, where it can be performed, must respond to the destruction of this present with more than feeling: with responsibility to the collective, staked out by the agential self. That, at least, is the potential of cliché.
In This Issue
All the essays in this volume find rich possibility in cliché — often in artists' engagements with the banally oppressive economic landscape and oppressively banal cultural landscape that cliché betrays. Angela Allan, in "For the Love of Work: Reading for the Cliché," reads from novels by Raven Leilani and Emily Henry to consider how clichés of romance have been applied to our relationship to work. Allan observes how readily the cruel optimism that we bring to the conventions of romance apply to labor: the easeful, normative, collective promises of marriage and family, stock phrases and stock plots. Like romantic love, work promises a "more complete, fulfilled self." Unpeeling the optimistic fantasies from Henry's and Leilani's texts, Allan shows that we learn that "work should be easy to love," while "the ideology within the cliché is that one should love work, even when it is hard." She argues that reading for cliché helps us to grasp the direction of our optimism: our fantasies of work drive, in fact, towards "a desire for work to matter," in a capitalist economy that strips labor of its libidinal potential and reduces it to "a travesty of necessities."
A number of the contributors in this issue explore how cliché has been used to evade and ironize stereotypical markers of identity in the representation of characters from marginalized backgrounds. Connor Spencer, in "Cliché's Cringe: Aesthetic Judgment in Percival Everett's Erasure," observes the cringe elicited by the novel's clichéd representations of Bill, Monk's queer brother. Bill's desires are "conventionally materialistic, his self-stylization is unoriginal, and his manner of speaking is trite." He's tasteless, a problem for Monk, the author protagonist of the novel, who hungers toward aesthetic virtuosity. Yet as Spencer points out, to cringe is often to recognize our proximity to the cringe-worthy object. "What if the embarrassment of cringe, an affective response that narrows our distance from the typified object, belies an anxiety over the process of typification immanent to cliché?" Part of the critical force of cliché, he suggests, is that it "induces discomfort over the possibility that one might be reduced to a similarly circulable type."
For Siraj Sindhu, similarly, the deployment of racialized stereotypes by Zadie Smith, Salman Rushdie, and Kaveh Akbar, in their depiction of western Muslim characters, instigates an uncomfortable affective response that we should not, nonetheless, mistake for untruth. In "The Uses of Caricature in the Western Muslim Novel," Sindhu argues that the genre employs the "truthful misrepresentation" of caricature neither to confirm nor dispel Islamophobic stereotypes, but to "reveal the agency and processual self-realization" of western Muslim characters as they achieve complex and hybrid social identities. Kate Schneider approaches the use of cliché in representing minoritized subjects from a different angle in "Cottagecore Bob: Cliché and Queer Sanctuary in Robert Glück's Garden Writing," examining its deployment by queer artists in a bid to shield themselves from entrepreneurial performances of self. In the work of Robert Glück and Joe Brainard, Schneider finds artists leaning into cliché as a means of "earnestly inhabiting commodity culture." For Glück, she suggests, clichéd and commodified representations of identity act as a façade, behind which the writer can step to dodge the expectation that the minoritized subject nakedly perform interiority, "offer up sexual disclosures, and otherwise expend the self."