Leaks: A Genre

The May 16, 2017, cover of the New York Daily News parodied President Trump for sharing highly classified information with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak in a closed meeting at the White House.

The May 16, 2017, cover of the New York Daily News parodied President Trump for sharing highly classified information with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak in a closed meeting at the White House.

It is in this more specific sense that I discuss the leak as a genre, defined by Lauren Berlant as an "aesthetic structure of affective expectation," a "formalization of aesthetic or emotional conventionalities."1 Leaks come with expectations that someone is going to be embarrassed; that is part of their function as a genre. In turn, they also push slightly beyond Berlant's theory of the "waning of genre," an important and powerful corrective to Jameson's diagnosis of postmodern culture as a waning of affect. Berlant's point is that today's world sees not so much a dampening of the circulation of feelings but a disruption of how those feelings are supposed to be organized and mediated and of expectations regarding where to find them.2 You turn on a comedy, but somehow you land up in the genre of horror; you're breathless and then you're crying when you thought you signed up to laugh. Berlant's description of the contemporary, however, goes beyond genre in this sense of categories of cultural production. Genres are not only types of literature, movies, and music; they apply to other social categories as well, if by genre we mean a convention in which members of a public recognize themselves as having shared definitions of x: a comedy is supposed to be funny, yes, but also: a man is supposed to by y or America is supposed to be z. The waning of genre is then the waning of commonsense: an erosion of a sense of having something in common with others, whether a common object or experience or affect.

There are different ways of telling the story of a present losing a sense of commons or decoupling from structure, just as there are many different regimes or institutions whose disorganizing can be told. The story I lean on here is the historical shift from Foucault's disciplinary society — a society cut up into discrete institutions cut up into discrete roles — to Deleuze's society of control, in which sets of behavior are modulated rather than sequenced.3 In such a society, institutions — paradigmatically those of the bureaucratic state — fail to contain and maintain themselves and their infrastructures, in turn failing to discipline their members into appropriate behaviors and roles. The 1956 "Report to the Secretary of Defense by the Committee on Classified Information" explicitly identified leaking as a problem of failed discipline: "We have been told that information security is a state of mind and not a set of rules. With this we agree. We further think that a state of mind is part of morale, and as such is a facet of discipline, and discipline is a command function."4 As Lebovic argues, the midcentury security state increasingly turned to "regulating the employee rather than the journalist" in order to control leaks; the authors of this report similarly thought that leaks could be stopped if only employees of government agencies, understood essentially as soldiers, could be disciplined.5 They doubled down on a program of disciplinary society, strengthening institutions in order to administer proper behavior. But such a strategy seems increasingly untenable as institutions become larger, more distressed, more virtual, and more permeable. The explosion of leaks in the sixty years since 1956 symptomizes a condition of disciplinary decay, a government whose institutions cannot program the expected behaviors and in turn cannot contain its information.

  1. Lauren Berlant, The Female Complaint: The Unfinished Business of Sentimentality in American Culture (Durham: Duke University Press, 2008), 4, 216. Berlant thereby echoes but elaborates earlier work in reception theory, most influentially the "horizons of expectation" in Hans Robert Jauss, "Literary History as a Challenge to Literary Theory," trans. Elizabeth Benzinger, New Literary History 2.1 (1970): 7-37.[⤒]
  2. Lauren Berlant, Cruel Optimism (Durham: Duke University Press, 2011), 6. Berlant explains that "all genres are distinguished by the affective contract they promise" (66).[⤒]
  3. Gilles Deleuze, "Postscript on Control Societies," in Negotiations 1972-1990, trans. Martin Joughin (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 177-82.[⤒]
  4. Charles A. Coolidge et al., "Report to the Secretary of Defense by the Committee on Classified Information" (Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Defense, November 8, 1956), 8.[⤒]
  5. Lebovic, Free Speech and Unfree News, 169.[⤒]