Leaks: A Genre
Given the regularity with which governance presents spectacles of its weakness, the age of the leak might also have been the age of the de-tethering of citizen from state, a disruption of the contract by which subjects invest and submit to the security of the nation as a safeguard of their own autonomy. In this essay, however, I tell a different story about the attenuation of attachment between subject and state. I will argue that leaks provide a repeated ritual for re-attaching to the state, not in spite of but because of its fantastic diminishing of power to contain itself. To put it frankly: there are pleasures afforded by someone else being embarrassed, and the leak as a genre attaches people to the state because of the pleasure provided by it. To be sure, this is a re-shuffling of the terms of attachment, and one of the stories I tell in the following sections is how leaks participate in a movement from identification with the state to interaction with the state, in which the state is not an image of identical similarity but of affective difference and fantastic disrepair.
If the leak takes the decline of disciplinary society as a condition rather than problem, then the leak is not a symptom of genre's waning, but of a genre that emerges in order to process the waning of institutions.1 I begin in the following section by returning to an earlier period and the discursive precedent for the leaks of the past decade: the Pentagon Papers. Within three weeks at the end of June 1971, this leak produced more than a half dozen federal court opinions, one from the Supreme Court; hundreds of editorials; and many more memos and letters to newspaper editors, all of which assembled a common language for talking about leaks. By moving through this highly compressed and rapid development of discourse, I establish the contours of the genre we have inherited today. This is not to claim that the Pentagon Papers and more recent leaks are identical or even historically accurate analogs. While Daniel Ellsberg, the original source of the Pentagon Papers, has called for seeing a similarity between them and Wikileaks — both have the ambition and, according to Ellsberg, the means of interrupting "wars on false premises" — most scholars have begun to enumerate the many differences between the two projects. WikiLeaks dumps are incomplete archives — randomly selected documents rather than complete bounded volumes — and therefore lacking in both context and content.2 Relatedly, the sources of what Margaret Kwoka calls the "deluge leaks" of today's world lack the intimacy with and knowledge that former "whistleblower" leakers like Ellsberg had with the materials they were leaking.3 While the Times was a publisher of leaked information, WikiLeaks is more analogous to a source of leaked information, and sources lack the jurisprudential discretion the Supreme Court granted to the Times in 1971.4 The Times is an American company subject to American laws, whereas WikiLeaks is not (there could be no landmark Supreme Court case in which WikiLeaks was a party); and the Times is an organization of professional journalists subject to traditions and codes of appropriate deliberations over the management of information, whereas WikiLeaks is not.5 Perhaps most importantly, the informational situations in which the Pentagon Papers and WikiLeaks act are worlds apart; with his Papers, Ellsberg had a specific goal, and leaking was a means to an end, whereas WikiLeaks sometimes seems to "revel ... in the revelation of 'secrets' simply because they are secret."6 Ellsberg leaked because he had to, while WikiLeaks leaks because they can in a world of wider information accessibility and easier transmission.
- Theorists have long analogized genres to social institutions: here's René Wellek and Austin Warren in Theory of Literature: "The literary kind is an 'institution'—as Church, University, or State is an institution"; and here's Frederic Jameson in The Political Unconscious: "Genres are essentially literary institutions, or social contracts between a writer and a specific public ...." René Wellek and Austin Warren, Theory of Literature (New York: Harcourt & Brace, 1949), 226; Fredric Jameson, The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act (New York: Cornell University Press, 1982), 106. In some accounts, institutions not only analogize genres but are also their origin. Carolyn Miller, the leading theorist in this line of thinking, argues genres are based on "typical joint rhetorical actions" in a given culture at a given period of time, provisioned by the collective spaces within that culture. I follow the lead of these accounts recommending that the study of genre might help us study institutions — not any particular institution, but the fate of institutionalism itself, or the relative extent to which a society can be cut up into discrete spaces that administer discrete roles and "joint actions." For Jameson, for instance, the point was that genres, like institutions, could also become subordinated to late capitalist logics; it would then seem possible to make a study of how economic modes modulate institutions according to the modulations evidenced in genres. For Miller, generic instability could be explained by social instability: today, in a fragmented and diffuse society, we have fewer shared intentions and fewer scenes of collective action, and "[t]his may be why the whole matter of genre has become problematic." Carolyn R. Miller, "Genre as Social Action," Quarterly Journal of Speech 70.2 (1984): 158. For a meta-theoretical review of the "genre as institution" analogy, see David Fishelov, "Literary Genres as Social Institutions," in Metaphors of Genre: The Role of Analogies in Genre Theory (University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1993), 85-118.[⤒]
- Daniel Ellsberg, "Why the Pentagon Papers Matter Now," The Guardian, June 13, 2011. For comparisons between the Pentagon Papers and WikiLeaks, see Bruce E. Altschuler, "Is the Pentagon Papers Case Relevant in the Age of WikiLeaks?," Political Science Quarterly 130.3 (2015): 401; and Paul Farhi and Ellen Nakashima, "Is WikiLeaks the Pentagon Papers, Part 2? Parallels, and Differences, Exist," The Washington Post, July 27, 2010.[⤒]
- "Recent leaks encompass vast quantities of records that the leaker likely knows nothing about, if he or she has even read them." Margaret B. Kwoka, "Leaking and Legitimacy," U.C. Davis Law Review 48 (2015): 1390.[⤒]
- Bella, "WikiLeaks and the Institutional Framework for National Security Disclosures," 1472.[⤒]
- Derek E. Bambauer, "Consider the Censor," Wake Forest Journal of Law & Policy 1.1 (2011): 33-4.[⤒]
- Floyd Abrams, "Why WikiLeaks Is Unlike the Pentagon Papers," Wall Street Journal, December 29, 2010.[⤒]