Leaks: A Genre

I do not intervene in these debates because my interest is in the development of a discourse around objects, leaving to one side a comparison of objects themselves. Here, I draw some inspiration from Adena Rosmarin, who has argued a genre is "a kind of schema, a way of discussing a literary text in terms that link it with other texts and, finally, phrase it in terms of those texts ... We are able, then, to read texts that are different as if they were similar because we are able and willing to make the edifying mistake of classification."1 We read WikiLeaks as if they were like the Pentagon Papers; to show they are not equal is still to operate within the universe in which they are at least "linked." In particular, I track in the following section the language developed to discuss the Pentagon Papers in order to see the affective affordances developed by leaks as a genre. I then return, in the concluding section of the article, to the present and how the genre lives in a world of other unstable genres including a realist novel like Purity, which helps to further contextualize the leak and pick out some of its thematic dimensions.

The Pentagon Papers, or, How "Leak" Lost Its Scare Quotes

Before they became the "Pentagon Papers," the 47 volumes of United States-Vietnam Relations, 1945-1967: A Study Prepared by the Department of Defense were called the "Vietnam Archive." That was the headline when the New York Times began serially publishing excerpts from and summaries of the study in its Sunday, June 13, 1971, issue, and it returned in the headlines on June 14 and June 15 before the District Court of New York granted the United States a temporary injunction enjoining the Times from further publication. In the articles introducing the study, the Times drew most of its attention to the study's archival nature: its "7,000 pages — 1.5 million words of historical narrative plus a million words of documents — enough to fill a small crate."2 Perhaps the most frequent verbs used in the articles were "reveals" and its synonyms (e.g., the study "discloses a vast amount of new information"), and this language of uncovering, combined with the Times's protection of its source's identity, indicated the secret nature of the report. But the story was ultimately the information itself rather than how it had been uncovered: "The overall effect of the study ... is to provide a vast storehouse of new information — the most complete and informational central archive available thus far on the Vietnam era."3 The contents of the leak, rather than the leak itself, were what made this a front-page story.

Indeed, "leak" did not enter into the discourse until several days later, after and in response to the government's attempted actions to halt more disclosure. On Tuesday, June 15, the United States government filed for a restraining order against further publication from Judge Murray Gurfein, who had been appointed to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York by Richard Nixon and sworn into office only the day before. The text of the government's complaint, which the Times published in its June 16 issue, claimed that without injunction, "the national defense interests of the United States and the nation's security will suffer immediate and irreparable harm."4 The formula of "national security" versus free speech quickly came to characterize the debate over the Papers, and because Gurfein granted a temporary restraining order until the case could be heard — and because this order was successively renewed throughout the course of appeals through the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and then the Supreme Court, publication was effectively enjoined until the last Court's decision on June 30; it was this debate over the archive's release, rather than the archive itself, on which the Times necessarily focused its front page coverage for the following two weeks. On June 17, the Times devoted almost an entire page to a roundup of excerpts from other newspapers' editorials on the matter under the headline "World Press Overwhelmingly Supports Publication of Documentation of Vietnam." Those who praised the Times did so by reference to its courage of speech, often with an unsubtle dose of American exceptionalism (it was claimed such a freedom of press would not be possible in, for instance, France or Australia). The few who decried the Times did so by reference to "defense interests ... and the nation's security," often by way of the compromised syllogism that the nation's wartime enemies would want the documents; therefore those who wanted the documents were the nation's enemies.

  1. Adena Rosmarin, The Power of Genre (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1985), 21-22.[⤒]
  2. Hendrick Smith, "Vast Review of War Took a Year," New York Times, June 13, 1971, 1.[⤒]
  3. Ibid., 38.[⤒]
  4. "Texts of Government Papers in Complaint Against The Times and Judge's Order," New York Times, June 16, 1971, 18.[⤒]